Categories
Update

Cancellation Month

On Film Threat, the two hosts, Chris Gore and Alan Ng, discuss political correctness as film critic Roger Ebert understood it in 1995. The hosts float a theory about today’s culture war — “pop culture, the news, politics, everything” — finding its roots in the 2000 Supreme Court decision that put George W. Bush into office, not Al Gore. This theory blames leftists for the split, notice. They became filled with rage. Political correctness was a thing in the early 90s, but it was beaten down by consensus American opinion, perhaps led by common sense center-leftists like Roger Ebert. When it resurfaced during the Barack Obama administration, the last grasp on common sense had vanished. 

Chris Gore mentions the “cancellation” of Sasha Stone (@realsashastone), saying it was over a mere joke, and people should be able to make jokes. “If I was going to cancel people for dumb jokes, I’d have to cancel myself,” he said. 

Ms. Stone, an Oscar pundit and owner of the entertainment news site Awards Daily, faced advertiser withdrawal after she posted “White power!” on July 30 from the Awards Daily X account (formerly Twitter). The post occurred the day after a “White Dudes for [Kamala] Harris” supporter Zoom meeting. In addition to the withdrawal of a studio’s advertising dollars from Awards Daily and the departure of three prolific contributors from her website within two weeks. After the contributors bailed, they founded a new site. 

A more recent and quite notorious cancellation was of podcasters “Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan,” who lost advertisers and gained notoriety for chortling at a bad joke about desecrating the body of the assassinated conservative campus personality Charlie Kirk:

Welch and her “I’ve Had It Podcast” co-host, Angie Sullivan, issued a mealy-mouthed apology on Saturday, saying they shouldn’t have laughed at an “insensitive joke” and noting they would donate to a gun violence prevention organization. The apology came after sponsors started to bail and TPUSA spokesman Andrew Kolvet posted updates, suggesting 21 companies have severed ties or clarified they’re not associated with the show since their viral laughter over a morbid Kirk joke caused widespread backlash.

“There’s a huge online cancelation campaign from all the titty babies over at Turning Point that want ‘I’ve Had It Podcast’ to be canceled,” Welch said in a video and posted to Instagram on Sunday.

“Why is Turning Point spearheading this? Well, let me tell you why. They are in big trouble,” Welch continued. “Even Republicans are starting to question, ‘Are they worth it?’ They get millions of dollars in funding, and as everybody saw on Tuesday, they got L after L after L, because they’re losers and they lost.”

Brian Flood, “Welch doubles down on TPUSA feud, calls group losers after laughing at joke about killing Charlie Kirk again,” MSN (November 14, 2026).

Not exactly repentant. Or even mildly chastened for uncivilized partisanship.

Dave Chappelle, the comedian, infamously commented on the Charlie Kirk assassination during a major stand-up act, but the joke, such as it was, wasn’t very funny. Erika Kirk, Charlie’s wife, was not pleased, but Chappelle’s comment did not lead to a cancellation, other than a lot of fans now call themselves former fans.

Early November also had David Walliams, the Britain’s Got Talent judge and children’s author, lost a High Court bid to permanently enjoin ITV News and the Guardian from printing articles in which they named him as the anonymous celebrity accused by several women of preying on teenage girls as young as 15. Walliams denied the allegations, saying “I am not a sexual predator. I have not broken the law.” The concrete fallout, per PBS News, is that the BBC said it was pulling programs including Little Britain while reviewing “all material featuring and written by David Walliams on our platforms,” and his literary agency, Independent Talent Group, dropped him. HarperCollins had already dropped him last year over earlier allegations. But note, these actual cancellations follow accusations and no official charges, much less convictions, for crimes.

Comedian Russell Brand, however, was sent to prison for rape and a few other sex crime charges, in Britain, on Thursday, November 5, 2026. And immediately sent to prison. The allegations were two decades old, and were wholly based on testimony. They stirred up much controversy online. His wife, Laura Gallacher, read his first statement from prison on the couple’s “Sunday Service” YouTube show (6.6 million subscribers) on November 15, 2026. 

“I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for,” the convict declared, and also revealing that he had been transferred from Wandsworth to HMP Littlehey, which he described as “the biggest sex offenders’ prison in Europe.” The broadcast triggered a UK government investigation, since inmates are banned from broadcasting to media under the Prison Act 1952 — Downing Street called it “appalling.” 

Lawful imprisonment — even if a railroad job — is not considered “cancellation.” But the British  government’s request to YouTube to remove the specific Sunday Service presentation by Mrs. Brand does fall under the “cancellation” category. And YouTube’s decision not to cancel it, much less de-platform the channel, is a good example of resisting cancellation pressure. According to YouTube, the video did not violate its rules.

For a discussion of the actual legal case against Brand, you might not find a better job done than by the Dark Horse Podcast:

Categories
Thought

Virgil

Scinditur incertum studia in contraria vulgus.

The wavering crowd is torn into opposing factions.

Publius Vergilius Maro, The Aeneid, Book II, Line 39 (tr. Fairclough).

Categories
Today

Mayflower Compact

On what we would now render as November 21, 1620, Plymouth Colony settlers signed the Mayflower Compact. In the Old Style calendar, the date was November Eleventh.

Categories
international affairs political economy

Better Than Pesos?

As recent years have again reminded us, the dollar, like other currencies, is subject to inflationary weakening of its value.

But some currencies are more at risk than others. That being the case, a few countries’ governments, seeking to end the risk of hyperinflation, have resorted to dollarization. 

That’s the replacing of a more inflationary currency with the dollar.

Though not as good as gold, the dollar is much more value-retaining than a peso that can be easily eroded the next time an irresponsible administration crowbars itself into power.

When running for president, libertarian-leaning economist Javier Milei promoted dollarization of Argentina. But, notes another economist, Nicolas Cachonosky, talk of this dramatic reform receded after Milei became president. Why?

“In a 2025 interview, Economy Minister Luis Caputo said dollarization had been ruled out because Argentina lacked enough dollars.”

But countries like Ecuador and El Salvador that have largely switched to the dollar didn’t do so on day one. “Physical currency was exchanged gradually . . . while bank deposits and tax payments were redenominated into dollars almost immediately. In Ecuador, the central bank’s own dollar reserves grew during the transition rather than shrank.”

Cachonosky makes a good case that Milei’s government should emulate them. “Two good years, even four, are no substitute for a lasting solution.” Temporary stabilization of the peso may only be “a preface to the next crisis.” It would be harder to reverse a fully effected switch to dollars.

Dollarization is advantageous because it puts the base money outside the country’s banks and outside the reach of fiddling by the country’s politicians.

Unfortunately, in the U.S., we have no other foreign currency to peg our dollar onto. So our banks and pols remain free enough to mess it up.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Grok Imagine

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

Brandeis

If we desire respect for the law, we must first make the law respectable.

Judge Louis Brandeis, Cleveland Plain Dealer (October 15, 1912).
Categories
Today

A New Jersey First

On November 20, 1789, the state of New Jersey led the way to establishing the Bill of Rights by being the first U.S. state to ratify the constitutional amendments.

Actually, the state ratified on that date Article One of the original twelve, which has yet to be fully ratified as a constitutional amendment, and Articles Three through Twelve, which became the ten articles of the Bill of Rights. On May 7, 1992, the state ratified Article Two, which became the Twenty-seventh Amendment to the Constitution.

Categories
First Amendment rights litigation social media

Danger, Will Robinson!

Come the New Year, in the once-great state of New York, users of social media will be subjected to a ten-second warning message when they open up their apps: “The Surgeon General has warned that while social media may have benefits for some young users, excessive use may be associated with significant mental health harms.”

The “message would appear the first time a user 17 years old or younger opens the app each day and again for 30 seconds after three hours of use,” writes Josh Plauzé. “Any social media platform that has an ‘addictive feed, autoplay, and/or infinite scroll’ would have to display it.”

Like any good Reason writer, Plauzé focuses on a lawsuit brought against the requirement: “NetChoice argues that the law interferes with people’s access to information and compels private actors to spout the state’s opinion.”

Some will quibble with that “interfering” — as a trivial half minute.

And the private actors required to “spout the state’s opinion” are of the same kind who regularly do such things routinely, required by federal regulation to place nutritional information on foodstuffs, or those required by lawyers and insurance companies to print warnings on garment bags not to place them over your head.

It may very well be that social media is often harmful for the young, amplifying peer-pressure, facilitating pornography, delivering a barrage of propaganda — pressuring most to conformity and some even to suicide. Parents and schools should, arguably, prohibit smart phone use by the young. 

But what should the state of New York do?

Mr. Plauzé concludes that “the state’s finding that social media use ‘may be associated’ with harm doesn’t justify infringing on people’s right to free speech.”

I merely note that anyone with access to a Virtual Private Network (VPN) would be able to skip this state-mandated bother altogether.

Leading me to suspect that state politicians will increasingly side with China and demand an end to VPNs entirely. 

And that would be a major infringement on freedom.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


NOTE: A federal court already blocked Colorado’s nearly identical law on First Amendment grounds in November 2025, and NetChoice has challenged California’s version too — so the VPN workaround may end up moot.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Nano Banana and Grok Imagine

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

John Taylor

A government of laws and not of men, is a definition of liberty; a government of men and not of laws, of despotism.

John Taylor of Caroline, as quoted in Walter E. Volkomer, ed., The Liberal Tradition in American Thought (G. P. Putnam Sons, 1969)
Categories
Today

Biden’s Polyp, Harris’ Power

On November 19, 2021, President Joe Biden temporarily transferred his powers and duties to Vice President Kamala Harris before undergoing a colonoscopy, making her acting president from 10:10 a.m. until 11:35 a.m. This was the first time a woman held the powers and duties of the president of the United States.

Biden had a benign but pre-cancerous polyp removed from his colon during that procedure.

Categories
defense & war education and schooling ideological culture

Touchy About the Truth

Should children learning about the history of the United States be spared acquaintance with the facts?

I don’t think so. But teaching facts sure can get you into trouble. A California middle school teacher showed students a five-minute video produced by a conservative organization, PragerU, about 9/11. 

Statements like these by the young narrator are somehow controversial: “Nineteen Islamic terrorists, organized by the terrorist group that calls itself al Qaeda, directed by its leader, Osama bin Laden, and drawn from four Arab countries, also boarded planes that morning. . . . Within an hour after takeoff, these 19 terrorists would hijack the planes, brutally murder defenseless stewardesses and pilots, and killed 3,000 innocent people.”

In other words, what happened, as those of us around at the time remember.

Also controversial, the conclusion that America must resist its enemies: “We will always be faced with a choice: to surrender our freedoms or to preserve them. . . .”

Plenty in the video to debate, I’m sure. So let the students debate.

But opponents of remembering 9/11 and who was officially determined responsible have attacked the Bernardo Heights Middle School, “bizarrely accusing the teacher of sharing a ‘graphic’ video,”explains Breitbart, “that they say ‘harped’ on ‘Islamic terror.’” 

An outfit called freefamilybookswap complains about all the topics not covered in the five-minute video, and “demands” a “public written apology” from the school, as well as “mandatory anti-Muslim and anti-Arab bias training” with “Muslim and Arab families” “included in curriculum review.” 

Not only should we remember 9/11, schools should remember that their job is teaching, not bowing to pressure from those offended by facts.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Grok Imagine

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts