Retired engineer Wayne Nutt wants to be able to speak freely about engineering problems.
North Carolina, in the form of its Board of Examiners for Engineers and Surveyors, disagrees. The Board sought to prohibit his speech unless he obtained a professional license, and it threatened him with sanctions.
As Institute for Justice puts it, the Board ordered Nutt “to stop talking about math in public.”
In response, Nutt sued, with IJ’s help.
Nutt often writes letters or speaks at public meetings to discuss problems with the designs of buildings and other structures. He also testified in court about flooding of a housing development. This is what caught the attention of the Board, which claims that for Nutt to utter such testimony or any public statements enlisting his specialized knowledge is illegal, amounting to practicing engineering without a license.
“I like the freedom to be able to speak up,” Nutt says.
I sympathize with this desire, as did the Founders who gave us the First Amendment to protect freedom of speech. Fortunately, so does Chief Judge Richard Myers of North Carolina’s Eastern District. He has just issued a favorable ruling in the case.
“This is a win for more than just me,” Nutt says. “There are a lot of people in the same situation — people who have expertise that they’ve been blocked from talking about. This decision is an affirmation that the First Amendment protects all of our rights to share what we know.”
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
Illustration created with Midjourney
—
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
3 replies on “Again Allowed”
Much of YouTube is “practicing engineering” without a license. As offering any health advice is practicing medicine without a license. Also called living.
More control of your life by North Carolina Republikooks! I live in NC. The lKooks want control everything!
I don’t know whether it bodes ill or well that Andrew Shepherd Zoutewelle, a member of the North Carolina Board of Examiners for Engineers and Surveyors, is president-elect of the National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying. The NCEES is intrinsically an illiberal organization, seeking to maintain licensing of engineers and of surveyors. But the NCBEES took things even further, so we may infer that Zoutewelle is especially bad in terms of what he wants. But now he takes an experience of losing in court to his presidency. Perhaps he will become a voice for pragmatic moderation; perhaps he will look for sneaky work-arounds.
Of course, opponents of licensure fare best if its advocates are wild-eyed totalitarians, shrieking about “quacks”.