The spectacular fallout between Donald Trump and Elon Musk over the Big Beautiful Bill in particular (but deficit spending and debt accumulation in general) promises political watchers a big, ugly brawl.*
Now, billionaire Musk appears to be serious about his proposed “third party,” the “America Party.” A name perfectly designed to ruffle Trumpian feathers. It might steal some of the thunder of “America First” and “Make America Great Again.”
The president mocks the notion, saying that third parties “have never succeeded in the United States.”
Well, that is not exactly true. For a long time, it was second parties that had problems.
The first party, the Federalists, basically lost for a generation, finally withering away against the onslaught of that most American party of all, the Democratic-Republican.
When the victorious party reformed under the leadership of Andrew Jackson and Martin Van Buren to become the Democratic Party, the Whig Party emerged to counter-act Jackson’s imperial presidency. The Whigs had some success — if with a string of presidents almost no one remembers — only to lose ground to Democrats and then a whiggish replacement, the Republican Party.
Yes, Trump’s own party was a “third” party once.
And it achieved power largely because the Democrats split into two for the 1860 election, leaving a sectional plurality candidate (Abraham Lincoln) to win the Electoral College as a Republican.
In modern times, Republicans and Democrats have ably squelched challenger parties.
So Trump’s right — in spirit.
Now enter Andrew Yang, enthusiastic for the upstart. But how can his Universal Basic Income agenda fit with Elon’s fight against over-spending?
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
* Though, some wonder if the Trump-Musk feud isn’t all an act.
Ilustration created with Krea and Firefly
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts
2 replies on “Upstart?”
The name “the America Party” is awfully close to that of the American Party of George Corey Wallace, from which the later American Independent Party split.
As to America itself, it doesn’t need another chimeral coalition of the dissatisfied; America already has the Reform Party of the United States founded in 1995, by supporters of H. Ross Perot. (For a time, Jesse Ventura tried to persuade one Donald John Trump, a real-estate tycoon, to be its Presidential nominee. Can anyone tell me what came of that guy?)
The Whigs won two presidential elections — in 1840 and 1848. Both presidents died in office and the Whigs lost the next election. They split in the 1850’s. The northern Whigs (Abraham Lincoln among them) became Republicans and the southern Whigs joined the Democrats. Today, a third party can only succeed if it displaces one of the top two existing parties. Electing a president won’t be enough. Maybe the best we can hope for is for the Dems and GOP to reorganize themselves and form new voter coalitions..