Things are what they are, not their opposite. Can we accept that as a starting point?
Not if we’re scoring ideological points regardless of the cost to clarity.
Newsweek calls drug-war violence in Long Island “a harrowing example of free-market, laissez-faire capitalism.” To this, Cato Institute’s David Boaz objects that “the competition between the local Crips and Bloods [is described] in terms not usually seen in articles about, say, Apple and Microsoft or Ford and Toyota.”
Under a truly free market, the rights of buyers and sellers to peaceably trade are legally protected from theft and violence, and their contracts defended from fraud. Black markets, on the other hand, are made up of illegal exchanges, actively prohibited trade.
Sure, black-market trade has something in common with legal trade. As with legal exchanges, persons willingly participate in black-market trades and expect to benefit.
But economic activity that can easily get you jailed is fundamentally different in just this respect from that conducted in a relatively laissez-faire context.
The difference has consequences.
You can’t go to court if you have a grievance with a black-market trading partner or competitor. And persons less scrupulous, more violent, more criminal than the norm tend to be disproportionately represented among sellers of illegal goods that have especially big markups precisely because they’re illegal.
So Boaz is right.
The legal capitalism at K‑Mart, J. C. Penny, or a post-Prohibition-Era liquor store isn’t fertile ground for the gang warfare invited by the War on Drugs. We can’t tell the difference, though, if we ignore the difference.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
4 replies on “This Ain’t Laissez-Faire”
Perhaps Newsweak is spending too much time thinking about kneecapping their competitors.
Reading the article it appears the story title was selected by the editor, not the author.
Yes, a black market with be violent, corrosive and corrupt the society — and that is the best reason to stop the foolishness of the prohibition.
I Disagree. i say that thanks to the Black Market the foolishness of the prohibition is brought to attention.
Also many activities are actually black market and are extremely beneficial, conducted in peace and fortunately not taxed.
The more people are forced to go underground the quicker the machinery of regulation and actual corruption will be exposed and over ridden. When the State is feared we are its prisoners. We are in a new era not yet fully understood but the State is being ridiculed and eventually it will be ignored. The many people engaged in underground activities are hastening that day.
“The more people are forced to go underground the quicker the machinery of regulation and actual corruption will be exposed and over ridden.”
Uh huh. And for how many decades has the War on Drugs been raging and resulting in murders, including those by police raiding homes, which never would have occurred but for the War on Drugs?