Categories
First Amendment rights media and media people political challengers social media

The Ignorance of Censorship

Why is Tim Walz, Harris’s running mate, governor of Minnesota right now?

Perhaps because government censors — functioning through agents like Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook — made it harder to hear his opponent, Dr. Scott Jensen, during Walz’s 2022 re-​election campaign.

A shift in a few percentage points would have tilted things in the challenger’s favor. But Jensen had made the government’s response to the pandemic — including the tyrannical policies of Walz’s state government — a central theme of his campaign.

And in those days (as in these), all-​out censorship of various deviations from the government line was de rigueur. Disagreement about COVID-​19, both the nature of the infection and the wisdom of the government’s response, was among the targets.

Jeffrey Tucker asks “Why Did Zuckerberg Choose Now to Confess” to the fact that Facebook had done so little, in Zuckerberg’s words, to resist repeated pressure “from the Biden administration, including the White House … to censor certain COVID-​19 content”?

The answer to the uninteresting question “why now?” is standard CYApolitical calculus. In any case, the confession isn’t quite exhaustive; Zuckerberg doesn’t acknowledge the extent of the censorship. As Tucker notes, “every single opponent of the terrible policies was deplatformed at all levels.”

The single COVID-​contrarian piece by Tucker himself that slipped through the social-​media censorship net “by mistake” got an atypical tsunami of response. So what if Dr. Jensen’s message and arguments had not been perpetually smothered by government-​pressured social-​media companies?

Jensen may still have lost (Walz got 52 percent) but the point of elections goes further than a horse race. Where there is free speech, voters can learn something.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with PicFinder and Firefly

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)

See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

Zora Neale Hurston

There are years that ask questions and years that answer.

Zora Neale Hurston, There Eyes Were Watching God (1937), Ch. 3, p. 21.
Categories
Today

Switzerland

On September 12, 1848, Switzerland — known by endonyms Schweizerische Eidgenoßenschaft (German), Confédération suisse (French), Confederazione Svizzera (Italian), Confederaziun svizra (Romansh), Confoederatio helvetica (Latin) — became a unified federal state with a constitution limiting central government powers and providing decentralized state (canton) power patterned on the U.S. Constitution.


In 1880 on this date, H. L. Mencken was born. One of his earliest books was a debate with a socialist, The Men versus The Man (1910); his greatest lasting contribution was probably The American Language (1919) and its supplements (1945, 1948). His work has been collected in numerous anthologies, such as Alistair Cooke’s Vintage Mencken (1955) and the author’s own Mencken Chrestomathy.

Categories
Accountability government transparency

He Lied About Who Died Where

Lying about data was not uncommon during the late pandemic. 

In April of 2020, I noted one way pandemic statistics were muddied: by paying hospitals more to identify a patient, surviving or not, as a COVID patient than as something else. This was especially devastating to death stats, perhaps mildly (or even wildly) over-​stating the effect COVID was having.

But understating the death count, or shifting it from one location to another, was also a problem. 

“Former New York governor Andrew Cuomo personally edited a government report that undercounted the Covid deaths that resulted from his March 2020 directive forcing nursing homes to admit coronavirus-​positive patients, a congressional panel concluded,” explains James Lynch at National Review.

 “The New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH) issued a report in July 2020 faulting nursing homes for the spread of coronavirus in their facilities at the direction of Cuomo administration officials who ‘heavily edited’ the document, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus pandemic said in a memo released Monday.” As I prepare these words, that subcommittee is set to listen to the former governor’s testimony on “the directive and his administration’s apparent coverup of the death total.

“More than 9,000 Covid-​positive patients were admitted to nursing homes because of the ‘must-​admit’ order,” James Lynch adds.

Remember, Andrew Cuomo was once a star of the pandemic, hailed for “getting tough” on the spread of the virus, as in cracking down on church services — assumed (but never proven) to be the kind of “superspreader” events that “kill grandma.” He was so much a star of the brief, flaming epoch that he was awarded an Emmy for his performance. (It was later rescinded).

I guess lying — falsifying data — is a performance.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with PicFinder and Firefly

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)

See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

William Saroyan

A prudent man does not open an umbrella for one drop of rain.

William Saroyan, Madness in the Family (1988).
Categories
Today

The Eleventh of September

September 11 is the 255th day of 2024. Notable events on this date from previous years include:

  • 1390 — The Teutonic Knights began a five-​week siege of Vilnius in the Lithuanian Civil War (1389 – 92).
  • 1565 — Ottoman forces retreated from Malta ending the Great Siege of Malta.
  • 1649 — Oliver Cromwell’s Parliamentarian troops ended the Siege of Drogheda by taking the town and executing its garrison.
  • 1683 — Coalition forces, including the famous winged Hussars, led by Polish King John III Sobieski, lifted the siege laid by Ottoman forces, ending the Battle of Vienna.
  • 1714 — Barcelona, capital city of the Principality of Catalonia, surrendered to Spanish and French Bourbon armies in the War of the Spanish Succession, thus ending the Siege of Barcelona.

In non-​siege related history:

  • 1789 — Alexander Hamilton was appointed the first United States Secretary of the Treasury.
  • 1830 – The Anti-​Masonic Party held its first convention, one of the first American political party conventions. Four years earlier on this date Captain William Morgan, a former freemason, was arrested in Batavia, New York, for debt after declaring that he would publish The Mysteries of Free Masonry, a book against Freemasonry. Soon after he mysteriously disappeared.
  • 1851 — Escaped slaves led by William Parker fought off and killed a slave owner who, with a federal marshal and an armed party, had sought to seize three of his former slaves in Christiana, Pennsylvania, thereby creating a cause célèbre between slavery proponents and abolitionists.
  • 2001 — On September 11, “some people did something,” in the words of Rep. Ilhan Omar.