Categories
Update

The Anomalous Interloper

You may have seen headlines noting that 3I/ATLAS has changed colors again. You may also have seen reports that it has broken up, as one might expect of a comet this size.

The truth?

It has indeed changed colors.

And no, it has not broken up. Latest reports suggest that it is quite intact.

The color change is not shocking: changes in color have occurred roughly once every month or so. The initial color was reddish; in mid-approach (August-September) it appeared greenish; at perihelion, last month, it turned blue.

The headlines about 3I/ATLAS “breaking apart” appear to stem from misinformation or AI-generated videos circulating online. Neither NASA, ESA, nor peer-reviewed studies report a breakup.

No fragmentation: Post-perihelion images (e.g., November 5 from R. Naves Observatory, Spain) show a compact, fuzzy “ball of light” with a diffuse greenish-white coma (~0.6 arcmin diameter) but no visible tail or fragments. SOHO/LASCO C3 data confirms residual sunward jets and four faint tails from outgassing, not breakup. Mass loss is ~13–50% from evaporation (half-life ~6 months), but the nucleus (est. 1–6 km wide) remains whole.

Activity and trajectory: It’s outbound at ~62 km/s on its hyperbolic path (eccentricity >5), showing non-gravitational acceleration from outgassing recoil. Position: In Virgo constellation (RA 13h 26m 52s, Dec -06° 46′ 12″), low on the eastern horizon before dawn (~8–12° altitude). Magnitude ~14 (fading to ~18 by mid-Nov), visible with 15–25 cm telescopes from Nov 11.

Inexplicable Increase in Speed: An eleventh anomaly can be added to Avi Loeb’s official count. On October 29th, the interstellar object sped up and moved a bit outward from the Sun. Loeb figured to accomplish this the object wuld have to eject one-sixth its mass. A week later? Nothing observed. No ejecta. The likelihood of an artificial object just went up — or it being a form of life itself became a possibility. So far? No good explanation for the non-gravitational alteration in trajectory has been offered.

China released new data and images of the interstellar comet 3I/ATLAS (C/2025 N1) in early November 2025, filling a gap during the U.S. government’s ongoing shutdown. The key release came from the China National Space Administration (CNSA) on November 6, showcasing images captured by the Tianwen-1 (Zhurong) Mars orbiter. These were taken on October 3, 2025, from approximately 30 million km away during the comet’s closest approach to Mars (about 0.2 AU, or 30 million km). 

Details of the images: The sequence, obtained using the orbiter’s High Resolution Imaging Camera (HiRIC) with a 15.2-inch aperture, reveals a bright nucleus surrounded by a diffuse coma (thousands of kilometers across) and faint dust tails. The resolution is sharp enough to show structural details like asymmetric outgassing jets, though not as fine as Earth-based telescopes due to distance. CNSA described it as “one of the closest probe-based looks at the object to date,” highlighting its role as a testbed for the upcoming Tianwen-2 asteroid sample-return mission in 2025.

Scientific insights: Spectral analysis from the images confirms elevated CO₂ and CO emissions, consistent with pre-perihelion data, and no signs of fragmentation. Chinese astronomers noted the coma’s greenish tint from CN and C₂ fluorescence, aligning with September observations.

NASA, citing the federal government shutdown, has furloughed ~15,000 NASA employees and halted most non-essential operations, including public data releases and non-critical science processing, has not yet released any new post-perihelion images of 3I/ATLAS as of November 7, 2025.

Because of NASA’s silence, outrageous speculation is rampant. Who knows? Maybe some of it is warranted.

Categories
Thought

Robert Heilbroner

Even today — in blithe disregard to his actual philosophy — Smith is generally regarded as a conservative economist, whereas in fact, he is more avowedly hostile to the motives of businessman than most New Deal economists.

Robert Heilbroner, The Worldly Philosophers (1953), Chapter III, “Adam Smith,” p. 62
Categories
Today

JFK Won

Montana was admitted into the United States federal union as the 41st state on November 8, 1889. On the same date in 1960, John F. Kennedy defeated Richard Nixon in one of the closest presidential elections of the 20th century, becoming the 35th president of the United States.

Categories
ideological culture too much government

Memo to Mamdani Voters

New York City is expensive. Housing is expensive, often prohibitively so. The city has crime problems. Other problems.

Answers: Unshackle the housing market? Slash regulations and taxes? Make it easier to catch and punish bad guys? No. Prevent builders from supplying more and cheaper housing. Further hobble the police. Etc. Pro-Hamas socialist Zohran Mamdani has a slew of such pseudo-solutions. 

And has a large following.

In New York’s mayoral race, decided Tuesday, the Republican candidate was excluded by the city’s heavily Democratic tilt. The incumbent mayor was also nonviable. Scandal-plagued former Governor Cuomo was the main alternative to a reputedly charming Mamdani now claiming a mandate to rob the rich.

Song Ying is a 72-year-old New Yorker who escaped the Chinese communists in 1976. She “swam for eight hours from Shenzhen, then a small fishing village, to Hong Kong,” explains  The New York Times in a report on the growing generational divide among Chinese immigrants regarding the prospect of a socialist city. Song is dismayed by the strong support among young New Yorkers for Mamdani. She says — and knows — that socialism doesn’t work.

The Times belittles her concerns, stressing that Mao’s China is not the vision that Mamdani is selling. Yet upon winning, the mayor-elect asserted that his administration would prove that “no problem [is] too large for government to solve and no concern too small for it to care about.” Sounds like a government without limits.

Mamdani will not fix things. He offers as solutions more of the policies that caused current problems: more regulations; more taxes; more spending; more government in power and scope.

If a boulder is tumbling right toward you, demanding more and heavier boulders won’t stop you from being crushed.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Krea and Firefly

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

Kin Hubbard

We’d all like t’vote fer th’best man, but he’s never a candidate.

Kin Hubbard, as quoted in The Best of Kin Hubbard (1984).
Categories
Today

Rock, Return, Release, Rocked

1492: The oldest meteorite with a known date of impact struck a wheat field outside the village of Ensisheim, Alsace, France.

1504: Christopher Columbus returned from his fourth and final voyage.

1775: John Murray, the Royal Governor of the Colony of Virginia, started the first mass emancipation of slaves in North America by offering freedom to slaves who abandoned their colonial masters to fight on the British side during the Revolution.

1940: The original Tacoma Narrows Bridge collapsed in a windstorm a mere four months after completion.

Categories
folly too much government

How Socialists Learn

Not all socialists in mayoral runs won on Tuesday.

Sure, socialist/communist Zohran Mamdani is now Mayor Elect of New York, but Omar Fateh lost to the incumbent mayor of Minneapolis on a second counting of the city’s ranked choice vote system. The latter is a victory for old-fashioned city politics, but what is the former?

Mamdani obviously wants to take from the rich and give to the poor, with a lot of government workers shuffling the money in between rich benefactors and poor dependents. Running grocery stores, of all things: Mamdani seeks to bring the efficiency of the DMV to the food industry. 

But just how much harm can he do? 

He still has to balance city budgets, and if he wants to spend billions, he has to “raise” billions in revenue. He cannot simply spend money he’s created — Mamdani doesn’t control the money supply. After all, socialism doesn’t create wealth ex nihilo.

Further, he will face opposition on his many pipe dreams. Since he has almost no work experience, and none managing anything, he may also prove to be way over his head.

Worst case? If he pushes his dream earnestly and effectually in the Big Apple, the rich and industrious will flee. (A possibility so likely that it is worth stating multiple times: when fools vote socialist, the wise vote with their feet.) Mamdani may usher in Atlas Shrugged faster than any pro-capitalist political party ever could.

Which, though disastrous for the poor, might prove educational.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Krea and Firefly

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

Carl Benjamin

Diversity is Sauron’s strength — and that’s very much the theme of The Lord of the Rings.

Carl Benjamin, @SargonofAkkad, responding (November 3, 2025) to a tweet by Don McGowan of the previous day.
Categories
Today

Gandhi Arrested

On November 6, 1913, Mohandes K. Gandhi was arrested for participating in a march of Indian miners in South Africa.

Categories
First Amendment rights insider corruption local leaders

Vindictiveness vs. the First Amendment

Finally, the city council of Castle Hills, Texas, is doing the right thing by Sylvia Gonzalez, accepting a settlement to resolve years of litigation against the city for violating her First Amendment rights.

In 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in her favor, agreeing that courts may properly consider evidence that an arrest is retaliatory.

According to Gonzalez’s lawsuit, in 2019 city leaders had lashed out against the councilwoman for her support of a nonbinding petition to remove a city manager. The city’s weapon? A rarely used law that it wielded against her for “briefly and inadvertently having the petition among her papers” during a heated council meeting; she allegedly tried to “steal” her own petition.

Gonzalez was arrested and spent a day in jail — the real reason, according to her lawsuit, being her criticism of local leaders.

The settlement means that statewide training on “First Amendment retaliation” (presumably, how to avoid engaging in it) will be offered throughout Texas and, for Castle Hill officials, will be mandatory.

The city must also pay $500,000 in damages to Gonzalez.

Anya Bidwell, an attorney for the Institute of Justice, which represented Gonzalez in the suit, observes that the First Amendment “doesn’t come with handcuffs. This outcome sends a message to officials everywhere: if you retaliate against critics, you can be held to account.”

Let’s hope that not a whole lot of training is needed to safeguard local freedom of speech. The issue is not that complicated.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Krea and Firefly

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts