An attempt to kill the right of statewide citizen initiative in Oklahoma has failed. By a 5-4 decision, the state supreme court ruled SB1027 unconstitutional and void.
Among other burdens, the legislation sought to require that no more than ten percent of petition signatures could come from a county with more than 400,000 residents.
KGOU reports that this cap would have been imposed on only two counties, those of Tulsa and Oklahoma, who together “could contribute only 20% of a petition’s signatures despite being home to nearly 37% of Oklahoma residents.”
We’re trying to get rural voters more involved, burbled bill backers. Also, petitioners who secure signatures from only a few counties are “corrupt,” asserted State Senator David Bullard.
The court’s decision notes that the “supposed goal of incorporating more rural voters at the signature gathering stage would impose a significant burden on the right of petition. The caps seek to achieve the inclusion of some by requiring the exclusion of others. . . . By denying qualified legal voters the right to participate in the petition process, the caps violate Oklahomans’ constitutional right of petition.”
A dissenting judge replied that no one who wanted to sign a petition would have been stopped by SB1027. It’s just that their valid signatures might have been tossed as irrelevant later . . . that’s all.
So the idea was you could sign. But it would have been as if you hadn’t were you one of those benighted post-ten percent signers.
. . . The virtue of which still eludes me.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
Illustration created with Nano Banana
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts
One reply on “Right to Sign, Restored”
A bit less than 37% of the population of Oklahoma is contained in its two most populous counties. When it comes time to vote, those in the other counties can have enough of a say to pass or to halt a measure, regardless of how those in the two most populous counties feel.
Moreover, organizations who want to get on the ballot measures originating outside these counties are free to petition within these counties, to take advantage of the greater population density and so forth.