The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, as giddy as a coke fiend in a locked DEA evidence room, is egging on rogue politicians. Missouri’s have threatened to sue . . . to undo a citizen initiative passed to prevent politicians from easily undoing citizen initiatives.
“I could see lawsuits being filed against Amendment 6, saying that it is unconstitutional,” says Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins. “It takes too much power away from the elected state reps [and] state senators.”
“Go for it,” the Dispatch responds.
Missouri’s Pulitzer-founded paper supports the incumbent-hated measure but thinks that politicians pondering litigation would be doing the equivalent of running on banana peels. The Dispatch looks forward to watching them slip on those banana peels.
Unfortunately, seemingly hopeless attempts at political sabotage sometimes succeed. So I can’t be as eager as the Dispatch to see an actual lawsuit.
Missouri voters passed the measure in question, Amendment 6, by a 60-40 majority. It prohibits the legislature “from repealing or amending a citizen initiative unless at least 80% of both the House and Senate vote to refer a proposed change to the ballot, and voters then approve the change.”
The new law also prohibits the state legislature from making changes to weaken the citizen initiative — just like those sought in August by incumbent-referred, voter-trounced Amendment 4. It would have required a Yes from a majority of voters in every one of the state’s eight congressional districts, not just statewide, to pass a citizen initiative.
By passing Amendment 6, Missouri voters have won a great victory. And I don’t think that a lawsuit against it can succeed.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
Illustration created with Nano Banana
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts
One reply on “Voters Win in Missouri”
A Republican’s claiming that this amendment to the state constitution is itself unconstitutional seems to be akin to Democrats’ claiming that various measures passed by clear majorities are undemocratic.
A constitution can prohibit amendments of some sorts, and the constitution of the state of Missouri requires that amendments by citizen initiative be confined to one subject and add or revise just one article, and that constitution also requires that an initiative not appropriate monies outside those raised by the initiative.
The US Constitution insists that each constituent state have a republican government, and that legislatures determine the manner of appointment of Presidential Electors, subject to some exclusions.
The limits to amendment set by the state constitution are not violated by Amendment 6, and if a citizen initiative tried to seize the power to appoint Electors, it could be specifically stopped in the same way as some action by the state legislature violating the US Constitution would be specifically stopped.
Hoskins, then, seems just to be engaged in verbal foot-stomping, much as Chase Strangio is engaged in verbal foot-stomping about restricting some competitions to female participants.
But, indeed, judges and justices have also been noted to foot-stomp, and their stomping has more social force.