Categories
international affairs political economy

Better Than Pesos?

As recent years have again reminded us, the dollar, like other currencies, is subject to inflationary weakening of its value.

But some currencies are more at risk than others. That being the case, a few countries’ governments, seeking to end the risk of hyperinflation, have resorted to dollarization. 

That’s the replacing of a more inflationary currency with the dollar.

Though not as good as gold, the dollar is much more value-retaining than a peso that can be easily eroded the next time an irresponsible administration crowbars itself into power.

When running for president, libertarian-leaning economist Javier Milei promoted dollarization of Argentina. But, notes another economist, Nicolas Cachonosky, talk of this dramatic reform receded after Milei became president. Why?

“In a 2025 interview, Economy Minister Luis Caputo said dollarization had been ruled out because Argentina lacked enough dollars.”

But countries like Ecuador and El Salvador that have largely switched to the dollar didn’t do so on day one. “Physical currency was exchanged gradually . . . while bank deposits and tax payments were redenominated into dollars almost immediately. In Ecuador, the central bank’s own dollar reserves grew during the transition rather than shrank.”

Cachonosky makes a good case that Milei’s government should emulate them. “Two good years, even four, are no substitute for a lasting solution.” Temporary stabilization of the peso may only be “a preface to the next crisis.” It would be harder to reverse a fully effected switch to dollars.

Dollarization is advantageous because it puts the base money outside the country’s banks and outside the reach of fiddling by the country’s politicians.

Unfortunately, in the U.S., we have no other foreign currency to peg our dollar onto. So our banks and pols remain free enough to mess it up.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Grok Imagine

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
free trade & free markets ideological culture

Competition in Currency

Monopoly control of money is at the root of all kinds of evil.

As the Euro faces collapse, and the dollar’s value becomes increasingly unsteady, central bankers the world over worry about what to do next.

But it doesn’t have to be this way.

Last Thursday I mentioned monetary experimentation, including Ron Paul’s support for F.A. Hayek’s idea of competing currencies. In my Townhall column this weekend, I noted that Rep. Paul has done more than promote the idea “that government policy should allow all currencies to float, favoring none. . . . Last year he introduced the Free Competition in Currency Act, as Hayekian a piece of legislation as you could imagine.”Monopoly Money

Paul’s proposal is not merely a sign of the times, it is a sign of intellectual seriousness — in a politician, no less. In the early 1980s he had introduced a measure to return the United States to the gold standard. But now he is willing to let “the market decide” which monies should circulate.

We may know a lot more about money than we used to, but one of the things we’ve learned is that no one knows for sure how to manage an entire monetary system, the whole kit and kaboodle.

So, just as we don’t need a grocery czar or an “industrial policy” to micromanage either technological production or R&D, centrally managed money is just too hard for any one set of persons . . . to manage.

Competition in money and banking (sans today’s progressivist doctrine of “too big to fail”) would not only work, it would keep politicians from the extremity of irresponsibility.

For yes, today’s politicians rely upon the Federal Reserve. They need to keep the “printing presses” running to supply that special, hidden tax that funds their deficits: inflation.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.