Tonight, the undefeated Dukes of James Madison University will travel to play the Thundering Herd of Marshall University in a Sun Belt Conference college football game. My youngest graduated from JMU, so I feel heavily invested in the team.
Duuuuukes!
One might think this sport and spectacle a welcome relief from politics — and surely it is — but not entirely. Because, of course, these great college football programs are attached to public universities financed by us, by our tax dollars.
The problem? As The Athletic put it recently: “For the second consecutive year, James Madison looks like one of the best teams in the Group of 5. And for the second consecutive year, the Dukes are ineligible for the postseason.”
The Group of 5 are the five best football-playing conferences after the best five conferences known as the Power‑5. That’s pretty impressive — especially considering this is only the second year since James Madison made the jump from the second division into the first division of football-playing schools of higher yearning and earning.
JMU is in the big leagues; it can now play for the national championship. Well, not now. Again, this year, like last year, JMU’s football team is banned from playing in a bowl game or being declared the champion of the conference … even though last year they did win the conference … except for the rule that says they cannot win the conference.
This year, the Dukes are 6 – 0 and could perhaps go undefeated. What if College Football’s Magic Computers pick them as among the best? They would still be denied a chance to compete.
Why? Well, those are the rules the colleges and conferences have agreed on. The rationales don’t hold much water. It seems like a hazing ritual holdover to me.
But, of course, the universities can do whatever they want.
And suffering the harsh two-year punishment is not so terrible for the coach who will possibly have a decade-long career, or the university that will play on in perpetuity.
All the unfairness is placed on the shoulders of the student athletes. Denied the conference honors and the post-season play they deserve, these unpaid players who’ve earned millions for their schools have at least learned a lesson. When it comes to sports and money, the kids come last.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
Illustration created with PicFinder.ai
—
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
10 replies on “Un-Sportsmanlike Conduct”
Paul likes to play by his own rules!
These have been the rules for a long time. They were not just for James Madison.
Pam, unless you want to argue that every long-standing rule must be maintained unchanged, you need a different argument than that for which you’ve here grabbed. Paul of course believes that this rule should be repealed for everyone, not that JMU should be given a sole exception.
It is only now when his son is involved that he cares. Same rules for everyone!
Do you know anything about football?
Pam, his son isn’t involved. Paul became more aware of JMU and of this case because one of his daughters attended JMU (from which she was graduated). But why he learned of it is irrelevant to whether the rule is a good one.
As I’ve already noted, Paul of course believes that this rule should be repealed for everyone, not that JMU should be given a sole exception. So your “Same rules for everyone!” is yet another willful attempt to mischaracterize his position.
The rule is in effect. JMU knew the rules, the players knew the rules. Unless and until the rules are changed, them’s the rules!
Pam, some of the players would have been quite unaware when they enrolled that JMU were going to change divisions, those players didn’t make the decision to change divisions, and the players are Paul’s concern here.
Punishment for what? What are the rules you refer to that mean their record doesn’t matter and that JMU is not allowed to win the conference?
JMU transferred from one division to another. They are not being penalized for an infraction.
That’s my question. WTH is the rule all about?
How about a simple explanation.
( NO, I don’t follow college sports.)
Go Marshall!
Sorry but I have many family slums from there!