“California recall fails,” The Visalla Times Delta explained. As did KSBY, the NBC affiliate in San Luis Obispo. Not to mention The New York Daily News and The Chicago Sun-Times.
FiveThirtyEight analyzed “the failed California recall” at length. Even the South China Morning Post proclaimed the apparent democratic malfunction (reprinting an Agence France-Press report).
Yet the recall did not fail.
Sure, voters decided not to jettison Governor Newsom mid-term. But that’s not a failure of this century-old democratic check on power — not unless a whole bunch of the 64 percent voting to keep Newsom filled in the wrong oval on their ballot by mistake.
I almost wish that were so; it would be easier to correct going forward.
“In a state famous for its acts of direct democracy,” a New York Times feature informs, “detractors of this year’s special election say the recall process is democracy gone off the rails, a distraction from crises that require the government’s attention, and a waste of hundreds of millions of dollars.”
Some folks never complain about government spending until it comes to the cost of holding an election. Funny, that’s precisely when our money might actually be well spent.
“No one in the state’s Democratic leadership is suggesting the elimination of recalls,” The Times notes, merely “vowing to make it more difficult for them to qualify for the ballot.”
In other words, legislators intend to raise the cost . . . so as to fight wealthy interests, they’ll argue. With a straight face.
“In a sharp piece of political irony,” that Times’ piece bemoans, “it will take a referendum to decide whether to change this particular referendum.”
Which is a feature of the system, not a bug. That is, no fail there.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
—
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
3 replies on “Democracy Fail?”
More, please.
The same people wailing over the assault on voting rights are advocating for the elimination of Direct Democracy?!
California remains THE beacon of both voting rights and direct democracy
I had made the prediction that Newsom would beat the recall with a vote count of 100,000,000 votes. Turns out I wasn’t off by much.
Others have made the same comment.
“That’s precisely when our money might actually be well spent”: the average citizen earns nearly a $1000 for every referendum held accroding to an estimation of prof.Matt Qvortrup, political scientist,UK. There is a strong correlation, repeatedly proven by research,
between the frequency of referendums and a GDP per capita.