Categories
folly too much government

Sir Surtax

Paul Jacob is already tired of the new old nonsense.

When, one wonders, will politicians become less impressed with their wares and wiles?

The new New York mayor has taken city reins and unfurled his first major effort: begging for money.

Begging, that is, for it to be demanded from others.

“New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani called on state lawmakers Wednesday to approve a 2 percent personal income tax increase on the city’s wealthiest residents,” writes Kimberly Hayek* for The Epoch Times, “as well as a hike in the corporate tax rate in a bid to close a multibillion-​dollar budget gap.”

Though Mamdani proclaims a new era of city and state working together, there is nothing new in his pitches for more taxes to redistribute to various voters, rather than attempting to build (or restore) a good foundation for normal social and business life.

Ms. Hayek does her duty, though, telling the old, old story of class-​envy politics. “Estimates suggested it” — a 2 percent surtax just for the “very” rich — “could create approximately $4 billion annually to support increased public services and affordability programs, as well as offset costs for broad social investments while not saddling middle- and low-​income residents.” 

But that’s merely the politician’s “theory.”

In reality, writes Hayek, “France’s experiment with a similar surtax on high incomes underperformed revenue projections. It yielded €400 million in its first year against an expected 1.9 billion euros.”

Same-​old story. Zohran Mamdani was never a breath of fresh air.

Just another old-​timey demagogue.

Mamdani may never tire of his schtick, but when will New Yorkers wake up … and yawn?

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


* Great name, eh?

PDF for printing

Illustration created with Nano Banana

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *