When asked to condemn terrorism, another liberal leader in the Duma, Ivan Petrunkevich, famously replied: “Condemn terror? That would be the moral death of the party!”
Not just lawyers, teachers, doctors, and engineers, but even industrialists and bank directors raised money for the terrorists. Doing so signaled advanced opinion and good manners. A quote attributed to Lenin — “When we are ready to kill the capitalists, they will sell us the rope” — would have been more accurately rendered as: “They will buy us the rope and hire us to use it on them.” True to their word, when the Bolsheviks gained control, their organ of terror, the Cheka, “liquidated” members of all opposing parties, beginning with the Kadets. Why didn’t the liberals and businessmen see it coming?
That question has bothered many students of revolutionary movements. Revolutions never succeed without the support of wealthy, liberal, educated society. Yet revolutionaries seldom conceal that their success entails the seizure of all wealth, the suppression of dissenting opinion, and the murder of class enemies.
Gary Saul Morson, “Suicide of the Liberals,” First Things (October 2020).
Categories
Gary Saul Morson
1 reply on “Gary Saul Morson”
We often discuss the collusion between the Republican and Democratic Parties to exclude third parties and independents.
The collusion between the political right and political left to exclude liberals is quite similar. And one device that the left and right use is abuse of the word “liberal” itself.
The Constitutional Democratic Party of Russian was a coalition of reformers who imagined the state as an instrument of positive, humanistic intervention, such as imposition of an eight-hour workday.